StockData

RLI vs Selective Insurance

RLI and SIGI side by side, both in fire, marine, and casualty insurance. Figures are trailing twelve months unless noted, from SEC filings and end-of-day prices.

How RLI and SIGI compare

RLI and Selective Insurance are about the same size, with market caps of $6.5B and $6.1B.

On earnings, Selective Insurance is cheaper: it trades at 12.3× trailing earnings, against 16.5× for RLI.

RLI grew revenue faster over the last twelve months (4.6% versus 4.0% for Selective Insurance).

RLI keeps more of each dollar of sales as profit, with a net margin of 20.3% compared with 9.4% at Selective Insurance.

Both pay dividends: RLI yields 6.6% and Selective Insurance 1.7%.

Selective Insurance scores higher on the StockData Score (14 against 10 for RLI), which adds up 30 checks on valuation, growth, past performance, financial health and dividends.

Key numbers

A dot marks the better figure where higher or lower is clearly better.

MetricRLISIGI
Size and price
Market cap$6.5B$6.1B
Share price$70.66$102.62
Change, 1 year11.7%30.8%
Change, 5 years30.0%31.4%
Beta (5Y)−0.370.35
Employees1,1932,800
StockData Score
Total score1014 (better)
Valuation score13 (better)
Growth score04 (better)
Performance score5 (better)3
Health score00
Dividend score44
Valuation
P/E16.5×12.3× (better)
P/S3.3×1.1× (better)
P/B3.8×1.8× (better)
EV/EBITDA–8.3×
P/FCF12.2×5.3× (better)
PEG–0.43
FCF yield8.2%18.8% (better)
Fair value$58.19$108.50
Margin of safety−21.4%5.4% (better)
Growth
Revenue growth (TTM)4.6% (better)4.0%
Revenue growth, 5Y average13.9% (better)12.8%
Net income growth (TTM)11.9%25.6% (better)
EPS growth (TTM)12.6%28.2% (better)
EPS growth, 5Y average20.4% (better)12.9%
Profitability
Net margin20.3% (better)9.4%
FCF margin27.4% (better)20.9%
Return on equity22.1% (better)14.7%
Financial health
Altman Z-score1.54 (better)0.98
Piotroski F-score66
Dividends and buybacks
Dividend yield6.6% (better)1.7%
Payout ratio109%19.6%
Years of dividend growth212 (better)
Dividend growth, 5Y average22.0% (better)10.8%
Buyback yield–2.5%
Shareholder yield6.6% (better)4.3%
Ownership
Held by institutions95.6%90.0%
Held by insiders1.6%0.94%
Insider net buying, 12 months$1.5M (better)−$2.1M
Superinvestors holding1–
Short interest, % of float9.4%–

Go deeper

Other comparisons

For information only, not investment advice. Check the source filings before relying on any figure.