StockData

Selective Insurance vs Universal Insurance

SIGI and UVE side by side, both in fire, marine, and casualty insurance. Figures are trailing twelve months unless noted, from SEC filings and end-of-day prices.

How SIGI and UVE compare

Selective Insurance is the larger company, worth 4.5 times as much as Universal Insurance ($6.1B against $1.3B).

On earnings, Universal Insurance is cheaper: it trades at 6.1× trailing earnings, against 12.3× for Selective Insurance.

Universal Insurance grew revenue faster over the last twelve months (5.5% versus 4.0% for Selective Insurance).

Universal Insurance keeps more of each dollar of sales as profit, with a net margin of 13.9% compared with 9.4% at Selective Insurance.

Both pay dividends: Selective Insurance yields 1.7% and Universal Insurance 1.6%.

Universal Insurance scores higher on the StockData Score (15 against 14 for Selective Insurance), which adds up 30 checks on valuation, growth, past performance, financial health and dividends.

Key numbers

A dot marks the better figure where higher or lower is clearly better.

MetricSIGIUVE
Size and price
Market cap$6.1B$1.3B
Share price$102.62$48.69
Change, 1 year30.8%41.5%
Change, 5 years31.4%217%
Beta (5Y)0.350.20
Employees2,800929
StockData Score
Total score1415 (better)
Valuation score34 (better)
Growth score4 (better)1
Performance score36 (better)
Health score00
Dividend score44
Valuation
P/E12.3×6.1× (better)
P/S1.1×0.8× (better)
P/B1.8× (better)2.1×
EV/EBITDA8.3×–
P/FCF5.3×3.7× (better)
PEG0.43–
FCF yield18.8%26.7% (better)
Fair value$108.50$56.24
Margin of safety5.4%13.4% (better)
Growth
Revenue growth (TTM)4.0%5.5% (better)
Revenue growth, 5Y average12.8% (better)8.4%
Net income growth (TTM)25.6%90.0% (better)
EPS growth (TTM)28.2%88.7% (better)
EPS growth, 5Y average12.9%60.1% (better)
Profitability
Net margin9.4%13.9% (better)
FCF margin20.9%21.6% (better)
Return on equity14.7%40.8% (better)
Financial health
Altman Z-score0.981.24 (better)
Piotroski F-score66
Dividends and buybacks
Dividend yield1.7% (better)1.6%
Payout ratio19.6%9.5%
Years of dividend growth12 (better)0
Dividend growth, 5Y average10.8% (better)0.00%
Buyback yield2.5% (better)1.9%
Shareholder yield4.3% (better)3.5%
Ownership
Held by institutions90.0%78.0%
Held by insiders0.94%14.5%
Insider net buying, 12 months−$2.1M (better)−$10.7M
Short interest, % of float–4.4%

Go deeper

Other comparisons

For information only, not investment advice. Check the source filings before relying on any figure.